Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Thursday, November 11, 2010

Notes from IGDA, part 1 (John Vechey, Popcap Games)

As promised/threatened, here's the first installment of my notes from the various talks, seminars, roundtables of this year's IGDA Leadership Forum. It's lengthy, but there was a lot of really good material to comment on.

IGDA LF, November 4th, 2010

Notes from opening speech, John Vechey (founder, Popcap Games)

I'll admit to coming into this talk with minimal interest. I knew very little of Popcap aside from the most basic of common knowledge: they make high quality, polished games and they pretty much created the Casual Games space. My own ignorance makes that sound like a fairly dismissive summation, which is unfortunate, because that's kind of like downplaying the significance of the mathematician who told Descartes, “You know what? I know it'd be tough to draw, but you should have a third dimension.” Who was that guy? Oh, nobody really. He just invented the Z axis, that's all.

Like I said, I started off fairly meh but the more I heard John talk the more interested I became. I'm going to just throw out some of the statements Mr. Vechey made and give my two cents about each one. Maybe you already know all of these points, but it was all news to me.


A 20-person company turned down a $60 million offer to sell

This actually happened early on at Popcap. The impression I came away with here is that everyone at Popcap wanted to keep making fun and they didn't feel that would happen if they sold the company. Maybe it was a matter of timing, maybe it was the prospective buyer...I don't know. But here's how I read it: these cats were presented with the choice of instantly becoming millionaires or staying true to their vision for their company. And they chose door #2. Respect.


Popcap is now up to 375 people and has been around for a decade

OK, so how'd that “no, thank you, we don't want your sixty million dollars” thing turn out for them? Pretty darned well, apparently. I'm not enough of a Pollyanna to believe that they created a superior future for themselves by being idealistic – although the ability to remain true to your vision is, I think, an indicator of values that fertilize the soil of success. Rather, I think they also had some pretty great leadership, excellent execution, and a boatload of persistence.

Every game would be better if it included a social graph (a la Facebook)

This is a pretty sweeping statement, but John's example of Minecraft is tough to refute. Let's just say I'm not sold on the absolute nature of this comment, but Mr. Vechey knows a heckuva lot more than I do about it. So if I had to recommend paying heed to his opinion versus mine...

Stay connected with the customer

Really, I think there could be an entire lecture – or series of lectures – on this topic. There's a ton of information to discuss here and I'm only bringing you a poorly drawn snapshot of the tip of the iceberg. Games that maintain a connection with the customer on any and every imaginable level have a great probability of making the customer happy and enhancing the game developer's revenue. A very simple example would be providing a web game X that rewards an achievement after 30 minutes of gameplay. And that achievement gives you $5 of in-game credit towards items you can purchase in game Y. What has that done for the consumer? What has it done for the developer?


Item-buy is a better business model than $60 purchase + $20 (or even $5) DLC

This makes me cringe a little, since my background is almost entirely one of AAA development – an arena in which providing attractive DLC is considered almost critical to getting a project greenlit. Almost nobody in the AAA space stops making a game after they ship it.


“I don't poo-poo technology but I haven't seen a technology problem that hasn't been solved by smart engineers.”

I put quotes around that because I made a point of exactly recording John's words when I heard that statement. It's a bit nitpicky, and I hate to look like I'm stooping to the level of soundbite-reporting so prevalent in this day and age, but I took issue with this because Mr. Vechey made it appear as though any idea with perceived value should still be pursued if it only represents a technical hurdle. Coming from a project management background as I do this smacks of – as Spock put it – two-dimensional thinking. Now, obviously the Popcap leadership is no bunch of dummies. And I'm sure they have a history of employing some pretty great technical problem solvers. But as a general rule if you get hung up on pursuing something because it's only a matter of time until your programmers find a way to overcome the current obstacle you might be taking a beating on opportunity cost, damage to your production pipeline, or even your long-term milestone schedule. Bottom line: If you aren't getting it done quickly (or at least on time) then it's not just a tech issue, it becomes a production issue.


“If it's a great game, we should make it”

My favorite quote from the whole thing. Because Popcap's games have traditionally smaller development cycles it was troubling a particular dev that he was working on something that could take three years to come to market. The dev asked if his work was relevant and this quote was Mr. Vechey's response. John went on to say that they should still make a game even if it will have a limited audience with a limited revenue potential – if it's great. It's one thing for someone to say that if they're an indie with a day job or an idealistic hardcore gamer looking at the industry from the outside. But when that comes from the founder and VP of Corporate Strategy for a successful company? Wow. Just...wow.

Tuesday, November 9, 2010

Back from IGDA Leadership Forum in San Francisco

This was my first IGDA event and I had a fantastic time. Even on registration night the day before the opening seminar I started meeting really interesting and passionate people (shout out to mis amigos at Kaxan Games!). It's great to be able to chat with folks who have been fighting the same fight as you have but who nonetheless have different perspectives and experiences.

And let's talk about the opening seminar! The inimitable Ike Harris of Zynga and the exuberant Kim Sellentin of SEGA Australia did a great job of setting the tone with their joint talk on Scrum implementation at their respective studios. And as if that wasn't enough they let me tag along when they popped off to In n Out for late night burgers.

The social aspects of the event were, in fact, even more meaningful to me than the purely informative nature of the sessions. Breakfast with the incredibly friendly Clint Keith, chatting about project management consulting with the unmistakable Michael Saladino, and discussing the horrors of suburban snow removal with Adrian and Kevin from Vicarious Visions all had a lasting impact for me.

I should really post my thoughts individually on each of the seminars I attended, so I'll save a few of the details for later. Suffice it to say that for folks in management and leadership positions in the industry, the IGDA LF is a highly recommended event.

Wolf Diary -- November 27th

I hope all the PMG folks at Activision know I have deep and abiding respect for them and that I've enjoyed working with them for the past 12 years. Otherwise they might take some of the comments in the latest Wolf Diary entry the wrong way. Adam, Matthew, Kekoa, Brian...you know I love you, right?

Guys?

Saturday, October 30, 2010

New Wolf Diary -- November 22nd

Sorry I'm posting this a few days late. My girls had an extra long weekend due to teacher conferences so we've been running around having fun. The new Madison Children's Museum is fantastic, by the way. I highly recommend the human-sized mousewheel.

Regarding the Wolf diary, I had forgotten about the efforts we went through to get a writer working on the story and dialogue with us. To be honest, I'm not even sure who eventually received writing credit on the game. When I was on the project, at least, it was Marianne Krawczyk. She had a very agreeable demeanor and seemed willing to work in the shifting sands of Wolfenstein's foundation. She didn't even complain when I picked her up from her hotel in a Honda Civic with no muffler. What a trooper. Read on.

Wednesday, October 27, 2010

A Note to Commercial Airline Flight Crews

If a passenger were to watch you quickly and distractedly amble around your aircraft (thankfully, not one I was boarding) as you perform the most disinterested preflight check in the history of powered flight, it might just have a negative impact on his view of you, your carrier, and possibly the industry as a whole. Admittedly, I may be off base in my observations. Maybe the officer in question was doing a great job of inspecting his aircraft. I barely know the difference between a pitot tube and a lavatory (and let's be clear, failure to distinguish between the two could result in a painful and embarassing scenario) so take my comments with a grain of salt.

Also, the flight crew of United 5872 from O'hare yesterday performed one of the best landings in heavy winds of all time. Thank you, gentlemen.

Friday, October 22, 2010

New Wolf Diary -- November 21

In which The Schedule comes under attack by the nefarious forces of CantWeHaveMoreDesignTime.
Unanesthetized dental surgery is also mentioned, but in no significant detail. Read on!